Skip to content

News

Is Vaping as Harmful as Smoking Cigarettes?

by Tariq Limalia 29 Mar 2024 0 comments

Quick answer: Most current evidence suggests vaping is not as harmful as smoking cigarettes, mainly because e-cigarettes heat a liquid instead of burning tobacco, so users are exposed to far lower levels of tar, carbon monoxide and many other toxicants. That does not make vaping safe: it still delivers addictive nicotine, vapour contains some potentially harmful chemicals, and long-term effects are still being studied. Vaping is only intended for adults who already smoke.

The key difference: burning vs heating

A cigarette burns tobacco, and combustion produces smoke containing thousands of chemicals, including tar, carbon monoxide, formaldehyde, arsenic and dozens of known carcinogens. These are the main drivers of smoking-related cancer, heart disease and lung disease.

A vape uses a battery-powered coil to heat e-liquid, usually made of propylene glycol (PG), vegetable glycerine (VG), flavourings and nicotine, into an aerosol. There is no tobacco burning, no tar and no carbon monoxide.

What the research says

  • Lower toxicant exposure: Studies of vapers' blood, urine and breath generally show substantially lower levels of many harmful substances than in smokers.
  • Not zero: Vapour can still contain formaldehyde, acrolein and traces of metals, particularly when coils overheat or dry hits occur.
  • Different expert positions: A 2015 Public Health England review estimated vaping to be around 95% less harmful than smoking; that figure has been widely debated, and other bodies, including the World Health Organization, take a more cautious view.
  • Unknown long-term effects: Vaping has not been widespread for long enough for decades-long studies.
  • Dual use: Smoking and vaping together keeps much of the harm of smoking.

Common misconceptions

"Vaping is exactly as harmful as smoking"

The weight of current evidence does not support this, because vapers are exposed to far fewer combustion chemicals. But the reverse myth is also wrong.

"Vaping is completely harmless"

Vaping still involves inhaling chemicals and an addictive drug. Non-smokers and young people should not start. Our vaping myths debunked article covers more of these claims.

If you're an adult smoker weighing it up

  • Speak to a doctor or pharmacist about all your options, including approved nicotine replacement products.
  • If you choose to vape, aim to stop smoking completely rather than doing both.
  • Use genuine products from a reputable store; counterfeit devices and liquids carry extra risks.
  • Avoid dry hits by keeping pods filled and replacing worn coils.

For more on making the change, read is vaping a good way to stop smoking?

Frequently asked questions

Is vaping safer than smoking?

Research generally finds lower exposure to harmful chemicals than smoking, but vaping is not safe and its long-term effects are still unknown.

Is the "95% less harmful" figure accurate?

It comes from a 2015 Public Health England review and has been debated. It is best seen as an estimate, not a precise measurement.

Does vaping contain tar?

No. Tar is produced by burning tobacco, and vapes don't burn tobacco.

Is nicotine the harmful part of smoking?

Nicotine is what makes smoking addictive and it affects the heart and blood vessels, but most of the cancer-causing chemicals in smoke come from burning tobacco.

Should non-smokers vape?

No. Vaping is intended only for adults who already smoke.

Vaping products are for adults 18+ only. Nicotine is addictive.

Prev post
Next post

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Thanks for subscribing!

This email has been registered!

Shop the look

Choose options

Edit option
Back In Stock Notification
this is just a warning
Login
Shopping cart
0 items